Thursday, May 21, 2020
Session with Adv. Mahendra Limaye on Cyber Laws and Cyber Safety
Session with Adv. Mahendra Limaye on Cyber Laws and Cyber Safety
Tuesday, May 12, 2020
Who has legal liability if Aarogya Setu Data is compromised?
The Aarogya Setu Data Access and Knowledge Sharing Protocol, 2020 was notified
by Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology on 11 May 2020. This has
again led to new debate regarding whether after this notification Aarogya Setu
app Data is safe? Adv Dr Mahendra Limaye, a cyber legal consultant, analyzed the
notification and his reading of the notification is as below.
Functioning of Aarogya Setu app as per notification relates to technology
and data management and certain necessary steps required to be taken to ensure
its effective operation to detect and mitigate the spread of Covid 19 pandemic
and enhance government preparedness at all levels. So the aim and object of the
Aarogya Setu App was never a question and it is much applauded move by the
government.
In order to ensure secure collection of data, protection of personal data
of individuals and efficient use and sharing of personal or non-personal data
for mitigation and redress this notification was specially issued. So we must
understand that this notification was fall out of many objections raised
towards security of the personal data collected through this app and about
accountability of the data collected through this app and specially when some
hacker claimed about vulnerability of this huge database. This response also
shows government’s responsive approach to security concerns raised about the
app and this is welcome move.
The
notifications says that in order to formulate appropriate health responses for
addressing the COVID-19 pandemic, data pertaining to persons who are infected,
at high risk of being infected or who have come in contact with infected
individuals is urgently required. This data includes demographic data, contact
data, self assessment data and location data, collectively called ‘response.
The demographic data includes the name, mobile number, age, gender, profession
and travel history of an individual. Contact data covers data about any other
individual that a given individual has come in close proximity with, including
the duration of the contact, the proximate distance between the individuals and
the geographical location at which the contact occurred. Self assessment data
means the responses provided by that individual to the self assessment test
administered within the Aarogya Setu mobile application. Finally Location data
means data about the geographical position of an individual in latitude and
longitude. So the broad categories of data collected through this app by
government is once again made public by this notification.
The
notification also states that the Ministry of Electronics and Information
Technology, Government of India (“MeitY”) is designated as the agency
responsible for the implementation of this Protocol and its developer, the
National Informatics Center shall, under this Protocol be responsible for
collection, processing and managing response data collected by the Aarogya Setu
mobile application.
So it is highlighted that MeitY will be only supervising
authority. So the government has brought NIC in picture for protection of
entire data in the capacity of developer and made its role minimal in capacity
of implementer.
Highlights of Principles for collection and processing
of response data:
a. Any response data and the
purpose for which it is collected by NIC shall be clearly specified in the
Privacy Policy of the Aarogya Setu mobile application.
b. NIC shall collect only such
response data as is necessary and proportionate to formulate or implement
appropriate health responses. Further, such data shall be used strictly for the
purpose of formulating or implementing appropriate health responses and
constantly improving such responses.
c. NIC shall process any data
collected by it in a fair, transparent and non-discriminatory manner.
d. Contact and location data
shall by default, remain on the device on which the Aarogya
Setu mobile application has been installed after such data has
been collected. It may be uploaded to the server only for the purpose of
formulating or implementing appropriate health responses.
e. Contact, location and self
assessment data of an individual that has been collected by NIC shall not be
retained beyond the period necessary to satisfy the purpose for which it is
obtained which, unless a specific recommendation to this effect is made in the
review under Para 10 of this Protocol, shall not ordinarily extend beyond 180
days from the date on which it is collected, after which such data shall be
permanently deleted. Demographic data of an individual that has been collected
by NIC shall be retained for as long as this Protocol remains in force or if
the individual requests that it be deleted, for a maximum of 30 days from such
request, whichever is earlier.
f. The response data shall be
securely stored by NIC and shall only be shared in accordance with this
Protocol.
Principles for sharing of response data have also been
stated which highlights that 1) Response
data containing personal data may be shared with various government
agencies/bodies where such sharing is strictly necessary to directly formulate
or implement an appropriate health response.2) Response data in de-identified
form may be shared with various bodies with whom such sharing is necessary to
assist in the formulation or implementation of a critical health response.3)
NIC shall, to the extent reasonable, document the sharing of any data and maintain
a list of the agencies with whom such data has been shared.
Obligations of entities with which response data is
shared are like use of such data strictly for the
purpose for which it is shared, the data accessed and used by such entities
should not be retained beyond the period necessary to satisfy the purpose for
which it is shared, in any circumstance; such data shall not ordinarily be
retained beyond
180
days from the date on which it was accessed, after which such data shall be
permanently deleted etc.
The main concern is who is liable for any privacy violations
committed through security breach of Aarogya Setu App? This notification does
not provide any clarity to said concern. It was clarified that any violation of
these directions may lead to penalties as per section 51 to 60 of the Disaster
Management Act, 2005 and other legal provisions as may be applicable. Legal
position for the protection of sensitive personal information under section 43A
of Information Technology Act 2000 is that state cannot be made responsible in
case of breach of data or lapse in protection of sensitive personal data.
Through this Notification State has clarified that it is acting only in
supervisory capacity and National Informatics Center, which is developer of the
Aarogya Setu app will own entire responsibility as far as security and sharing
of Response Data is concerned.
As regards section 51 to 60 of the Disaster Management Act
they have one important protection as related to breach of data and the
protection is “ unless he proves that the offense was committed without his knowledge or that he exercised all due
diligence to prevent the commission of such offense”.
In case of any data breach through Aarogya Setu app defense
will be always available that all due diligence was observed to prevent the
commission of offense like Data Theft etc. So in my view this notification clearly
fails to provide any specific measures which government has suggested for
protection of Data of millions of Aarogya Setu app users. Also the other
question remains is whether the provisions of the Disaster management Act can
be enforced after Disaster is over? If data breach is reported after present
pandemic is over then whether these provisions can be enforced, remains a
question in my mind.
Advocate Dr. Mahendra Limaye
About the author- Advocate Dr
Mahendra Limaye is Cyber Legal Consultant and Cyber Law practitioner in India.
He specifically practices in Information Technology Act based litigation's
before Civil as well as Criminal Courts in India. He has obtained his doctorate
on topic Fundamental Rights and Cyberspace. He can be contacted on mahendralimaye@yahoo.com or + 919422109619.
Thursday, May 7, 2020
"Bois Locker Room" and what next we are waiting for?
Its only when such episodes get national publicity
suddenly the whole digital world becomes awake, all so called human right
activists become active and start hue and cry about regularisation of social
media etc. These are the same people who were at forefront in matter of Palghar
incident and came down heavily of Information Technology Act section 66A which
ultimately led to abolition of the same.
What we sow we reap is old saying. Our society consists
of the same people who had seen section 66A of I T Act as draconian and don’t
wanted social media to be regulated. They saw regulating social media, which
according to them is the biggest tool of freedom of speech and expression, as
curtailment of Fundamental Rights and ultimately our Apex Court also viewed in
similar perspective.
The underlying object of regulating social media
with reasonable restrictions was never debated seriously and nobody has taken a
futuristic view about the same. With many similar incidents gradually happening
every passing day and when it comes to flash point in Bois Locker Room issue,
people again started debating the need to regulate social media. So is this
completion of the circle?
We stared with section 66A which regulated online
posts on various grounds in 2008, then came 2015 Apex Court Judgement striking
down section 66A of I T Act and now with the incident of Bois Locker Room there
will be again enactment of some provisions for regulating social media. Unfortunately
all this is happening when most awaited regulation regarding Personal Data
Privacy is being studied by Indian Parliament. When in Puttuswamy case in July
2017, a need was felt to have a regulation to protect privacy of the
individuals and the panel was formed under chairmanship of Justice Shrikrishna
(Retd.) to draft new regulation. The Shrikrishna commission has submitted draft
bill in July 2018 and it was before parliament since then and recently a high
powered committee is again set up to finalise the same.
If this is the level of priority for Privacy
regulation in India and in absence of section 66A of I T Act there in no
deterrence to perpetrators of such heinous acts through Social Media and Bois
Locker Room incidents will happen regularly.
What was the incident?
An 18 year, Class 12 student resident of
Noida, started an Instagram group named "Bois Locker Room", on which
obscene messages and morphed photos of underage girls were shared. 27 more
students of prominent Delhi schools have been members of the group, some were
underage and some 18 and older. The chatroom, conversation was exposed by a
girl, who was targeted in the group chats and this has drawn massive anger,
shock and disgust on social media. The manner in which Class 11 and 12 students
casually discussed "gang-raping" girls, sexualized and slut-shamed those
in screenshots of chats have gone viral on Twitter and other social media."We absolutely do not allow behaviour that promotes sexual violence or exploits anyone, especially women and young people, and have taken action on content violating our Community Standards as we were made aware of it," was the Facebook spokesperson’s response on the episode. The official age of joining Instagram is 13 or above in India as per their policy.
In India 13 year old person is not capable of entering into contract but these social media giants are making mockery of Indian regulation by allowing these young kids by providing them such platforms.
There are basically few questions which need serious debate according to me.
1) Should social media be regulated? If yes by whom?
2) Should social media obey right to be forgotten or
right to modify one’s personal information?
3) Do we have Personal Date Privacy Act as a national
priority?
4) Could porn contents be specifically moved to different
domains like .xxx?
5) Is this encroachment of digitalisation in every walk
of life is must?
6) Are people really aware about threats posed by AI and
other activities?
7) When Cyber Awareness Education will be taught to
digital netizens?
Unless we collectively provide answers to
these questions such incidents are bound to happen. For that instance even if
you go through confession pages of schools you will find many such indecent
acts by students, who I am sure are not teens. If we investigate this scam, the first question comes to my mind is from where the teen got hold of the photographs? All of us know the answer is simple. The victims themselves might have uploaded these photographs without thinking that these photographs could be grabbed by anyone and used on any place on the earth. At the time of uploading picks they were never told what the consequences of such acts are. I can go one step further and caution the readers that there are syndicates which are trapping many persons carrying out indecent act on camera and blackmailing them.
Second question is regarding how teens of age group13/14 were given such liberty by their parents to use social media without proper supervision. Are those parents liable for punishment for acts of their minor wards? Yes they must be definitely penalised similar to new provisions in Motor Vehicle Act, where parents are liable for fine/jail term in case they handover vehicle to their under aged ward. Without parents supervision digital education will prove to be a disaster in country of digital illiterates.
Third question is under which provisions of law action will be taken and against whom?
This is very tricky situation because as per reports few are teens and will be protected being Juvenile. Those who are above 18 might not have passed any comments which could be strictly punishable under provisions of I T Act. If IPC is applied then act being committed in Cyber Space must be covered under provisions of I T Act and which provisions of I T Act are applicable? It’s not Identity Theft nor Personating nor Violation of Privacy as per various provisions of section 66 of I T Act. Can section 67 or 67A of I T Act be imposed?
What next is real question and answer for same is lies in answers of Seven questions posed by me earlier.
The power of collective will by self restraint, to make social media a better place can only make it possible. All the stake holders like we netizens, government of all the nations, social media giants along with search engines should come forward and extend best possible solution which will decide the course of future. From my side CYBER AWARENESS IS THE ONLY MANTRA which we are relentlessly carrying out since last decade.
Advocate
Dr. Mahendra Limaye
About the author- Advocate Dr
Mahendra Limaye is Cyber Legal Consultant and Cyber Law practitioner in India.
He specifically practises in Information Technology Act based litigations
before Civil as well as Criminal Courts in India. He has obtained his doctorate
on topic Fundamental Rights and Cyberspace. He can be contacted on mahendralimaye@yahoo.com or + 919422109619.
Tuesday, April 28, 2020
Adv Dr. Mahendra Limaye’s reply on “don’t stifle our digital economy with overbearing regulations” published in LiveMint.
Adv. Sidhant Kumar has written an
article titled “don’t stifle
our digital economy with overbearing regulations”, which was published
in Live Mint. The article is about Personal Data Protection Bill 2019 and if
passed what would be its effect on Indian Digital Economy.
The author believes that our
leading digital economy received resounding validation through
Facebook’s $5.7 billion investment in Jio Platforms. This according to me may
not be entirely appropriate view. It could be at the most seen as marriage of
convenience or compulsion. The debt trap in which Reliance Industries is
passing through after huge investments in Jio and sharp fall in oil prices
world over is well-known and its deal with Saudi company Armaco has already ran
into trouble. On the other side Facebook wants to have some influential partner
in India which will influence Indian government policies and more particularly
on crypto currency and digital money by companies not having their offices in
India. So this deal should not be treated as validation of India as investment
destination by companies based in US.
The author also has raised five major objections in proposed
PDPB 2019, which are baseless and without application of legal mind and needs
to be countered. So let’s go by the objections raised by learned author.
Firstly the author feels that pivot of the framework appears
to be a domineering mandate to be given to a data regulator, structurally
geared to intervene rather than facilitate.
The functions and duties
of Data regulator as per proposed bill are 1) It shall be the duty of the
Authority to protect the interests of data principals, prevent any misuse of
personal data, ensure compliance with the provisions of this Act, and promote
awareness about data protection. 2) monitoring and enforcing application of the
provisions of this Act; 3) taking prompt and appropriate action in response to
personal data breach in accordance with the provisions of this Act; 4) maintaining
a database on its website containing names of significant data fiduciaries
along with a rating in the form of a data trust score indicating compliance with
the obligations of this Act by such fiduciaries; 5) examination of any data
audit reports and taking any action pursuant thereto; 6) monitoring cross-border transfer of personal
data etc.
These duties and functions are mostly
regulatory and appellate authority is prescribed if any arbitrariness is observed
by the authority or anyone is aggrieved by the order of regulator’s mechanism. So
it’s totally wrong to state that mandate of only intervening is wasted in hands
of regulator. Rather prompting awareness programs and ensuring compliance from
various fiduciaries shows its responsibilities as facilitator.
Second, the Bill has
broad-based restrictions on the transfer of data overseas from India, which
could hive our market off from the global digital economy.
This is totally misconceived and
misleading statement since the bill at section 33 makes it clear that subject
to the conditions in sub-section (1) of section 34, the sensitive
personal data may be transferred outside India, but such sensitive personal
data shall continue to be stored in India. Section 34 (1) says the sensitive personal data may only be transferred outside
India for the purpose of processing, when explicit consent is given by the data
principal for such transfer, and where—
(a) The transfer is made
pursuant to a contract or intra-group scheme approved by the Authority and (b)
the Central Government, after consultation with the Authority, has allowed the
transfer to a country or, such entity or class of entity in a country or, an
international organisation. This makes it amply clear that permissions can be
sought for transfer of data overseas in exceptional circumstances’. So this itself explains the concerns of the
author are false and if he is advocating that data be transferred cross border
without any government restrictions then I think he should show any example across
the world where any country has allowed free flow of data trans-border without
any restrictions.
Third objection of the author regarding the Bill seeking to protect privacy by way of
what looks like a regulatory sledgehammer that imposes extensive compliance
requirements with little aid to data protection needs explanation from author
himself. If he thinks some provisions of Data protection are arbitrary or
impractical he should point out those specific provisions rather than painting entire
provisions alike. When stakes involved are high the degree of care and
protection needs to be the utmost and same principle seems to be followed in
framing the law. Data Protection is core and the worldwide examples of social
media giants flaunting these norms are in open domain. The level of security
needs to be balanced taking into considerations millions of digital illiterates
exposed to digitalisation and author seems to be concerned about these digital
sharks which are ever eager to latch on
the private sensitive personal data on the users.
Fourth objection is that the Bill sets forth an inflexible
framework that is bereft of any formal consultative rule-making process, which
is likely to stifle innovation in the sector. The author seems to be unaware
about how much deliberations and discussions and public debates took place
prior to introduction of this bill and shows his lack of knowledge. He is more
concerned about what will happen to innovations in this sector as they all will
be regulated in some or the other law in future. Lawlessness has prevailed in
digital world for long and we are paying price for the same.
Lastly his objection is about substantial portions of the
Bill being out of sync with international data protection practices, which
could blunt India’s competitive advantage as a digital market. Again these are
hollow statements without any proof to back the same. The author seems to be
fond of most loved one keys known as Ctrl C and Ctrl V and used them to throw baseless
allegations without coming up with any concrete evidence.
Being an Advocate it was expected of him to put forward some
evidence/logic backing his allegations but he seems to have leveled the allegations
without making any preparations and with some ulterior and oblique motive. What
it is, presently not known to me, but at least after this rebuttal it is
expected from the author to come up with more studied document which will
enlighten illiterates like me, more about the topic.
Some counters to his
specific statements:
1) Each Facebook user in Asia (except China) generates only
$11 of advertising revenue a year. But who
is beneficiary of this revenue, the author has not explained. Does our
government get any tax on the same?
2) In its present form,
the Personal Data Protection Bill could result in the largest expansion of the
regulatory state in India since economic liberalization in 1991. The author has forgotten that The
Personal Data protection bill’s objective is to “ensure growth of the digital
economy while keeping personal data of citizens secure and protected.” It was
also mentioned in preface of Personal Data protection bill that the issue of
data protection is important both intrinsically and instrumentally.
Intrinsically, a regime for data protection is synonymous with protection of
informational privacy. As the Supreme Court observed in Puttaswamy’s, “Informational
privacy is a facet of the right to privacy. The dangers to privacy in an age of
information can originate not only from the state but from non-state actors as
well. We commend to the Union Government the need to examine and put into place
a robust regime for data protection. The creation of such a regime requires a
careful and sensitive balance between individual interests and legitimate
concerns of the state.”
Instrumentally, a firm legal framework
for data protection is the foundation on which data driven innovation and
entrepreneurship can flourish in India. Fostering such innovation and entrepreneurship
is essential if India is to lead its citizens and the world into a digital
future committed to empowerment, experiment and equal access, observed by Apex
court in India and thereafter Justice Shrikrishna committee was formed and
which recommended the draft Personal Data Protection Bill after due
deliberations and consultations with the experts.
3) He criticizes the creation of a Data Protection Authority with the power to impose
penalties to the tune of 4% of a company’s global turnover but forgot that Competition Commission of India has also imposed in
Feb 2018 a penalty
amounting to 5% of the average revenue generated from India over the three
years to FY15, an amount of 135.85 crore and a maximum penalty of 10% can be
imposed under the Act.
4) The author criticizes that the Bill
contains substantial restrictions on the transfer of sensitive personal data
(including financial and health data) outside India and authority’s prior
approval would be needed for any such transfer. Has the author gone through provisions of Personal Data protection
and more specific to Health data prevailing across globe and more particularly
in US? The US healthcare act HIPPA and HITECH mandates even non US companies to
be HIPPA compliant if they are handling any health data related to citizen of
US.
5) According
to the author, Bill also requires large players to have data protection
officers physically located within India. These proposals could have an adverse
impact on our digital economy, the basic characteristic of which is
connectivity beyond barriers. When
Indian companies handling any data related to health parameters of US
citizen, they have to be compliant with US laws but when Indian law mandates
Data Protection Officer to be located in India the author dislikes the same.
The present provision does not say he should be Indian Citizen and the physical
presence of Data Protection officer in India will rather ease the burden on
many foreign companies as DPO will be in better position to understand the
situation on ground while performing his duties. This in turn will create more
job opportunities to Indian people and will have positive impact on Indian
economy.
6) The outside world is
likely to see these measures as less about protection and more about
protectionism. It needs to be
mentioned that most of the provisions of PDPB 2019 are inspired or influenced
by GDPR which is already operative in European Union and GDPR is never seen as
protectionism of data of European citizen etc. And when our Apex Court has been
vocal that Right to Privacy is integral part of our Fundamental Rights and
there can be always reasonable restrictions (as contended by author) on
exercise of Fundamental Rights in exceptional circumstances.
7) The Bill contains extensive compliance requirements, including the
conduct of audits and impact assessments to be filed with the Authority. It would have been better if the author
has been kind enough to make few suggestions to make compliance requirement
simpler. The normal accounting audits by tax authorities were also seen as
stringent initially. The personal data in today’s world of digitalisation is
equivalent to free and fresh air required for one’s physical survival. It’s
fundamental responsibility of state to see that all its citizen get free and
unpolluted air for which there are many environment friendly regulations
related to Pollution, Plastic usage etc. passed by parliament. Similarly the Personal
Data being part of fundamental rights, its protection becomes responsibility of
our government and if stringent provisions are needed to safeguard interest of
Indian Citizen, the parliament has every right to do so.8) The author has shamelessly conceded that the fulcrum of the Reliance-Facebook deal would be the transformation of WhatsApp, a messaging platform, into a one-stop platform for a large number of everyday transactions. Facebook’s bet on India underscores India’s enormous potential as a market. But author has not taken any pain to study what is revenue model of Facebook or Whatsapp? How the only messaging platform, Whatsapp, without any commercial or revenue generating model could survive this long? It has been proved time and again that most social media companies trade in data and make enormous amount of money by such trade alone and still there are few who want that trade should remain unregulated forever. The PDPB only intends to have some safeguards in place where the privacy or confidentiality of the information should be maintained by social media companies or for that matter all data fiduciaries.
The author should have used his
knowledge to point out the specific lacunas, if any, in the PDPB2019. Lot of
time is already wasted in passage of this crucial act which is concerning Fundamental
Right of, practically every citizen of this country.
I hope that to my best abilities I
have tried to advocate need for passage of Personal Data Protection Bill 2019
at the earliest. The amendments are always possible once the law is implemented
and enforced and tested on various fronts.
Advocate Dr. Mahendra Limaye
About the author- Advocate Dr
Mahendra Limaye is Cyber Legal Consultant and Cyber Law practitioner in India.
He specifically practises in Information Technology Act based litigation's
before Civil as well as Criminal Courts in India. He has obtained his doctorate
on topic Fundamental Rights and Cyberspace. He can be contacted on mahendralimaye@yahoo.com or + 919422109619.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)